A Clockwork Orange
Plenty of critics believe that A Clockwork Orange missed the mark on the intention of the book, but was celebrated for its graphic nature and the horrible personality of the main character. Plenty of individuals believe that A Clockwork Orange is an unnecessarily artsy snooze-fest that lacks substance outside of shock value.
Lost in Translation
Most Bill Murray movies receive overwhelmingly positive reviews but Lost in Translation polarized the usual critics. Some loved it, some hated it, but for the most part, all critics agree that Murray and Scarlett Johansson didn't "sell" their characters. Who could blame them though?