Caddy of Cadboro Bay – Cadboro Bay, WA
The monster in Cadboro Bay can be hard to see, but older locals swear that it's there. Caddy is similar to Nessy of Loch Ness. It just swims around without causing harm to humans, but it's extremely hard to find.
The Rhinelander Hodag – Rhinelander, WI
This is apparently a monster that locals in Rhinelander have seen... The Rhinelander Hodag has been described as a "stumpy and ugly" creature that likes to eat dogs. No, thanks.